Monday, April 25, 2016

Is loop quantum gravity based on discretisations?

Sum of two spin networks for continuum limit of loop quantum gravity
Two spin networks, which can be interpreted as Hilbert space elements
describing truncations (or discretisations) of general relativity,
are summed. What is the physics of such states? 

This post is related to last week’s about criticism of loop quantum gravity and a comment I found in Sabine Hossenfelder’s blog. Saying that loop quantum gravity is based on discretisations quickly leads one to doubt that Lorentz invariance may be a property of LQG, as happened in the comment. So it seems worth to clear up this issue and precisely say in what context discretisations appear, in what context they don’t, and what this means for the physics that are described by LQG.

The canonical formalism of LQG is most suited to discuss this question, since one has a direct relation to general relativity as the theory which is quantised to obtain LQG. In particular, one really quantises continuum general relativity and the Hilbert space that one obtains thus has to be interpreted as the continuum Hilbert space. However, the elementary excitations on this Hilbert space, comparable to particles on a Fock space, are discrete quanta of geometry. They are the quantum operators corresponding to certain holonomies and fluxes that one can compute in the classical theory. A finite number of such holonomies however only captures a limited amount of the continuum geometry that is roughly equivalent to a discretisation of GR. Therefore, the (simplest) quantum states that one usually discusses in LQG, which also form a basis of the Hilbert space, have a certain interpretation as discrete geometries. This however doesn’t mean that there cannot exist any continuum states in this Hilbert space, since we can of course take arbitrary linear combination of basis elements, and thus, morally speaking, arbitrary superpositions of lattices. Gaining control over such states and understanding their physics is currently the main open problem in LQG. A computation in a simplified toy model explicitly showed that such quantum geometries can be consistent with local Lorentz invariance.

In conclusion, the Hilbert space of LQG contains elements which can be interpreted as discrete quantum geometries. In different approaches to LQG, these states are given a more or less fundamental status which might suggest that one is really dealing with a discretisation. However, one always needs to keep in mind that one can arbitrarily superpose such states and that the state of quantum geometry that correctly describes our universe at all scales should be searched for in a suitable continuum limit.

(As a short remark, this does not mean that states containing only a few quanta of geometry cannot be useful when one is considering certain truncations of the theory, such as cosmology. However, one then has to interpret those states in a coarse grained setting and properly understand the renormalisation group flow which relates the dynamics of continuum states to those of coarse grained few quanta states.)


  1. When i benefit your existing document. It might be top notch to examine everyone reveal with text throughout the coronary heart in conjunction with lucidity due to this vital difficulty may very well be easily viewed. idm crack

  2. This particular looks for example certainly superb. Most of these slight tips are made using availablility of cosmetic foundation interest. I like to him or her appreciably. idm

  3. I loved your article!! It has given me plenty to think about moving forward on my social media journey!Dashlane Crack

  4. It’s not my first time to pay a quick visit this web
    site, i am visiting this site dailly and obtain fastidious data from here

    anytrans crack
    adaware pro security
    dolby atmos apk

  5. Great, submit, very informative.
    I ponder why the opposite experts of this sector don’t realize this.
    You must proceed your writing.
    I’m confident, you have
    a great readers’ base already!
    filmora crack
    transmac license key
    synfig studio crack
    cubase pro crack with keygen free download

  6. This article is indeed a satisfying article that can help new Internet users.
    Who needs help with blogging?You can also visit my website. I hope to help you
    cyberlink powerdirector
    windows 7 loader with activator 2020
    avira antivirus pro crack
    google earth pro crack


  7. Sincerely, I am so glad I found your site, I accidentally found you while searching on google
    for something else, I am still here and I want to congratulate you on a nice post and
    a nice blog all over (love the theme/design too),
    I don't have time to watch anywhere in the minute, but I noticed and added
    your RSS feeds, so if I have time, I will return to
    read on, keep up the good work.
    stopzilla antivirus crack
    amcap crack serial key

  8. It is very interesting, you are an experienced blogger. I added your feed and I hope you continue your search
    great posts. We also shared your site on social networks!
    express vpn crack

  9. optimum! I want to do an internship while editing the website, how can I subscribe?
    For blog sites? This account helped me close a deal.
    I am a little familiar with your post, it provides a clear and bright concept.
    drivermax pro crack
    tubedigger crack

  10. This is really helpful and helpful information.
    I'm glad you just shared this helpful information
    site. Protect us like this. Thanks and sharing.

    pubg pc crack
    netlimiter pro
    aiseesoft blu ray player crack
    sketchup pro crack

  11. Its truly solid for you everything considered all window programming foundation. This site is tangling its article are head and boggling. I appreciated and bookmark this site on my chrome. This is where you can get all break programming in like way present in clear manner.

  12. Its genuinely strong for you everything considered all window programming establishment. This site is tangling its article are head and boggling. I appreciated and bookmark this site on my chrome. This is the place where you can get all break programming in like manner present in clear way.

  13. I like your all post. You have done really good work. Thank you for the information you provide, it helped me a lot. I hope to have many more entries or so from you.
    Very interesting blog.

  14. Is this a paid topic or do you change it yourself?
    However, stopping by with great quality writing, it's hard to see any good blog today.
    Enscape 3D Crack
    Windows 11 Download Crack
    Nitro Pro Crack
    Windows 10 crack
    Soothe 2 VST crack
    Ableton Live Suite crack
    Ami Pro crack

  15. PowToon Crack is software that helps the user to animate the presentations and can convert the presentation into a video quickly and easily. It is a web-based program that is used to animate the pre-made object and manipulate that pre-made object.

  16. Wow, great blog structure! How long do they have?
    have you ever blogged? you made blogging easy.
    The whole look and feel of your site is amazing, not to mention
    malwarebytes crack
    malwarebytes anti malware crack
    malwarebytes crack
    malwarebytes key

  17. At first glance, my first choice is an efficient application.
    In short, reliable user feedback has made it possible to download personal files and keep them safe.
    football manager crack
    activepresenter crack
    bolide movie creator crack

  18. Many thanks for sharing such incredible knowledge. It's really good for your Website.
    The info on your website inspires me greatly. This website I'm bookmarked. Maintain it and thanks again.
    I'm really impressed with your writing skills, as smart as the structure of your weblog.

    CorelCAD Crack
    Autodesk AUTOCAD Crack
    Ultra Adware Killer Crack


  19. your posting style is very amazing.. good keep it up!
    Soothe 2 VST Crack

  20. Intelliji Idea Activation Key is the best product to enjoy creative Java and is designed to stimulate the creativity of developers. In other words, the program is considered an excellent parser for both ergonomic design and static codes.
    Iobit Malware Fighter Crack
    Softros Lan Messenger Crack
    Mixpad Crack With Registration Key
    Wondershare Video Editor Crack
    Wysiwyg Web Builder Crack

  21. This site have particular software articles which emits an impression of being a significant and significant for you individual, able software installation.This is the spot you can get helps for any software installation, usage and cracked.

  22. I guess I am the only one who comes here to share my very own experience guess what? I am using my laptop for almost the post 2 years.
    Soothe 2 VST Crack
    Output Thermal VST Crack
    Effectrix VST Crack
    Spectrasonics Trilian Crack
    I Heart NY Crack
    Goodhertz All Plugins Bundle Crack

  23. So nice I am enjoying for that post as for u latest version of this Security tool.
    Top Crack Patch

  24. The post is quite informative as I could derive a lot on the topic by reading through it.
    Health Tips | Healthy Life Ideas | Health Care News in urdu

  25. Adaware Antivirus Pro Crack
    Great set of tips from the master himself. Excellent ideas. Thanks for Awesome tips Keep it up


  26. There are extremely a great deal of details like that to consider. Which is a wonderful point out raise up. I provide you with the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are actually questions such as one you retrieve the place that the most important factor might be in honest good faith

  27. FxFactory Pro Crack is the first visual plugin package software that allows you to change and create your own specific plugins for ultimate cut professional. Free Download at

    FCPX Auto Tracker Crack is an impressive video editor for Mac that enables users to edit videos in the most entertaining and professional ways.
    IPadian Premium Crack is not an emulator but a simulator. You can feel and see the differences between iOS and Android.
    VMware Workstation Pro Crack and BSD virtual machines on your Windows or Linux desktop using VMware Workstation Pro, the most popular desktop hypervisor.
    Wondershare Dr.Fone Crack is an efficient and brilliant software to restore any of the lost data of your system. It is very versatile and can run on many different hardware platforms, including mobile devices.
    SnapGene Crack a simple and secure method for arranging, picturing, and reporting ordinary sub-atomic science techniques.

  29. like your all post. You have done really good work. Thank you for the information you provide, it helped me a lot. I hope to have many more entries or so from you.
    Very interesting blog.
    GraphPad Prism Crack
    Avira Phantom VPN Pro Crack
    Enscape 3D Crack
    UltraISO Premium Crack
    VCE Exam Simulator Pro Crack

  30. I like your all post. You have done really good work. Thank you for the information you provide, it helped me a lot. I hope to have many more entries or so from you.

    pdf-to-excel-converter crack

    reimage-pc-repair Crack

    iperius-backup crack

    wonderfox-dvd-video-converter crack

  31. Download Software for PC & Mac
    You make it look very easy with your presentation, but I think this is important to Be something that I think I would never understand
    It seems very complex and extremely broad to me. I look forward to your next post,

    ScriptCase Crack
    Surfblocker Crack
    Octane Render Crack
    ZWCAD 2022 Crack
    Bolide Movie Creator Crack
    Advance Bulk Mailer Crack
    Apple Motion Crack

  32. I have been searching for a real site for a long time that can provide a decent backlink.
    FL Studio
    iMyFone AnyTo
    Advanced SystemCare Pro

  33. Thank you so much for sharing this amazing knowledge. It's really good for your website.
    The information on your site inspires me a lot. This website I'm favorite. Keep it up and thank you again.
    I'm really impressed with your writing skills, which are as smart as your blog structure.
    Bitdefender Antivirus Plus
    Bitdefender Internet Security
    Internet Download Manager
    SOUND FORGE Audio Studio
    Hard Disk Sentinel